| 2010 |
Sam |
Rock, Fresca, old pickles |
| 2013 |
Devon |
book he got from a homeless guy |
| 2014 |
Cross |
Bagels-a-month subscription, sent to Nelson's apartment |
| 2015 |
Neil |
Book found in on NYC stoop, full of dick drawings |
| 2016 |
Cross |
Nothing |
| 2017 |
Nathan |
the book, chained forever |
| 2018 |
Jordan |
An enormous box, containing a unicorn beanie baby that has I hate you Ron written on it |
| 2019 |
Sam |
Diamond to sapphire sign |
| 2020 |
Ryan |
Drove to Florida and delivered 3 long boxes of disordered comics |
| 2021 |
Karen |
Tadpole Terrarium |
| 2022 |
Sean |
Handmade wooden 'Failur' sign |
| 2023 |
Rachel |
Custom Spider Calendar |
| 2024 |
John |
Grave dirt |
| 2025 |
Charlie |
baseball signed by Brandon Lowe (Charlie's most hated baseball player) |