| 2011 |
Devon |
UF-themed Pregnancy Preparedness Kit |
| 2013 |
Sweeney |
Picture of Nathan giving the finger |
| 2014 |
Sam |
Nothing |
| 2017 |
F |
Scorpio Jacket, with pockets full of sugar |
| 2018 |
Neil |
The Book, with Chingo Bling attached and a Suck it, Neil bobblehead |
| 2019 |
Devon |
Nothing |
| 2020 |
Cross |
Drew Carey water |
| 2021 |
Skyler |
Live Laugh Love sign |
| 2022 |
F |
The book, thrown from a moving car |
| 2023 |
Nelson |
Hot-reveal mug of Barry Wood (that dude with a huge dong) |
| 2024 |
Jordan |
oh fuck everything is on fire, what did you do poster |
| 2025 |
Sean |
beloved wife trophy, found in the trash and customized for Sean |
