| Year | To | Gift |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Nelson | A Phish Binder, contianing a Vice article calling Phish fans pieces of shit |
| 2019 | Charlie | Fyre Festival tickets and a Kavanaugh joke |
| 2020 | F | third-gen ball painting |
| 2021 | Ryan | Rocky V + Presentation |
| 2022 | Karen | The Book of Karen, Green River Killer mug |
| 2023 | Nathan | Banana Phone, Encased in Tootsie Rolls |
| 2024 | Sean | membership to Tampa Bay Parrotheads Club; 5 o'clock somewhere shirt |
| 2025 | Neil | Veggie Tales - 4 great bible stories dvd, buried in a box of coal |
| Year | From | Gift |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Jordan | A homemade operation kit - A defaced Mickey Mouse doll, containing a balloon full of sriracha and a dbz blind box (sewn inside it) |
| 2019 | Charlie | Dick painting, continued |
| 2020 | Sean | Face bank |
| 2021 | Sam | Keyboard that can only type Born to Fish, Forced to Work |
| 2022 | Ryan | Fuckable Zombie Head |
| 2023 | F | Don't Bully Me, I'll Cum Shirt; spam assortment |
| 2024 | Nelson | Grave dirt |
| 2025 | Cross | a photo possessed by a malevolent spirit; a small rocking horse possessed by a benevolent horse ghost |