| 2014 |
Nelson |
Bagels-a-month subscription, sent to Nelson's apartment |
| 2015 |
Sam |
MTG - binder full (180 copies) of 'Complete Disregard' card |
| 2016 |
Nelson |
Nothing |
| 2017 |
F |
100 lbs of sugar poop |
| 2020 |
Nathan |
Drew Carey water |
| 2021 |
Charlie |
SHREK SEX STUFF |
| 2022 |
Skyler |
Nothing |
| 2023 |
Ryan |
Clearly Tampered-with Ferrero Rocher (they're all brussel sprouts) |
| 2024 |
Devon |
Bird house with a cat butthole and Free Luigi painted on it |
| 2025 |
Karen |
live spider; dead wasps; despicable me toy; possum flavored candy canes; wax lips |
